The United Kingdom is on the cusp of a significant energy transition, facing challenges that are as daunting as they are critical. As we phase out ageing nuclear reactors and plan the closure of our final coal power station, we anticipate a substantial shortfall in our base load electricity generation capacity. In this article, we will explore the pressing issues accompanying this transition, particularly focusing on our ambitious yet potentially challenging shift towards renewable but intermittent energies like wind and hydrogen, as well as the increasing reliance on electricity for powering modern technologies such as heat pumps and electric vehicles (EVs). These insights will underscore the urgent need to boost the UK’s energy production capabilities to avert a looming crisis.
Declining traditional power sources
Due to the age of many of the UK’s nuclear facilities, the Government is in the process of decommissioning these older sites, which will soon strip approximately five to six gigawatts of stable base-load power from the British grid. With many of the UK’s power stations being decommissioned during the next decade, other sources of renewable energy may not give us the surety of supply meaning we will need to use more of our gas-fired generation capacity. Simultaneously, the cessation of coal-fired power, while aligning with our environmental objectives, heightens the capacity gap. The UK’s transition from these traditional power sources will require significant investments in new technologies and infrastructure to ensure a stable energy supply.
When you combine these scenarios with the current state of our nuclear fleet, there is great cause for concern. Five of the UK’s power stations are currently generating electricity, while three are in the defueling phase, the last stage of their operational lifecycle before decommissioning. It might be possible to partially replace this base load energy loss with offshore wind power, but offshore wind power’s inherent intermittency makes it unsuitable for the continuous and stable supply required for base load energy. The variability of wind necessitates large-scale energy storage systems and significant upgrades to our grid infrastructure, both of which are currently limited and costly to implement. Economic costs, environmental impacts, policy uncertainty, and the need for coordinated planning further complicate reliance on offshore wind alone. Thus, a balanced energy strategy incorporating a mix of renewable sources, advanced storage solutions, and grid enhancements is essential to ensure a reliable and sustainable energy future.
Wind energy and hydrogen production challenges
The UK Government has set ambitious targets for wind energy and hydrogen production. Specifically, the aim to develop 10 gigawatts of hydrogen capacity by 2030, although more recent discussions suggest six gigawatts might be realistic. This goal necessitates an equivalent increase in electricity generation, primarily expected to be met through offshore wind. However, as of last year, less than 8 gigawatts of offshore wind capacity were under construction and the Government’s approach to pricing saw zero entrants for last year’s Allocation Round (AR). This has since been partially recovered in this year’s AR but was a further backwards step at a time it could be ill-afforded. This significant discrepancy raises serious doubts about our ability to meet hydrogen targets and reflects broader concerns about the scalability and rapid deployment required for wind energy to meet our very real national needs.
The dual role of hydrogen: fuel and energy storage
Hydrogen plays a pivotal role in our strategy for a cleaner energy future, presenting unique challenges and opportunities. Hydrogen’s role should be seen as not just a fuel but also as an essential component in energy storage. By converting excess wind energy into hydrogen during peak production times and then utilising it to generate electricity during periods of low wind, we can potentially mitigate some of the inherent issues associated with renewable sources, thereby enhancing the UK’s grid stability.
In fact, we have seen an explosion in Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) in recent times, and these are useful to help balance the grid in the ultrashort term, but they are only useful for hours rather than days when renewable energy generation falls short. These in turn need recharging and the length of time required can change dependent on the size of the battery and the available grid supply. With the right precautions, hydrogen can be stored indefinitely, which makes it attractive as an energy source when renewables are not producing and the BESS have all discharged.
There are several interesting applications – emerging electrolyser technologies will allow for reversible operation, meaning that hydrogen is produced when electricity is available and the system goes into reverse as a fuel cell to generate electricity from hydrogen when needed. Several UK gas-fired power stations are considering converting to partial or even full hydrogen capability, to use hydrogen as a like-for-like fuel swapping out methane (natural gas).
Embracing electrification
The shift away from traditional gas heating and power generation ,towards technologies such as heat pumps and electric vehicles, adds further complexity to our energy scenario. As the world and the UK transitions away from fossil fuels, it is very likely that many of us will bid farewell to traditional gas fires and boilers, embracing electrified heating systems in our homes instead. While beneficial for reducing carbon emissions, these technologies increase the demand for electricity and in-built competition for the emerging hydrogen industry. There is a significant gap in our current policy, which fails to integrate these technologies with the necessary infrastructure advancements and rapidly changing electricity generating profile. There are other electric heating systems available, but none of these are as efficient as heat pumps. Considering these frailties, the need for a revitalized push for energy efficiency and insulation, micro-generation such as solar panels on new housing and significant investments in battery storage solutions are essential steps towards developing a cohesive energy policy that works for all.
In addition to the challenges surrounding electricity generating capacity, the UK faces significant supply chain risks that could hamper the energy transition. For example, while the UK currently has only 4,000 trained heat-pump installers, it is estimated that we will need 33,000 by 2028 to meet growing demand. This gap highlights a critical bottleneck in the adoption of energy-efficient heating systems. Furthermore, the infrastructure for electric vehicles (EVs) is under strain, with long waits for the installation of EV chargers becoming increasingly common. Planning considerations, such as securing permissions for new energy projects and upgrading existing infrastructure, add another layer of complexity. These supply chain issues must be addressed alongside capacity constraints to ensure a smooth and timely transition to a sustainable energy future.
As well as this, we know that hydrogen is not the most efficient method of electricity production, having already been produced from electrical energy (and water) there are losses throughout the production and reconversion processes as no process can be 100% efficient.
Grid flexibility
Interconnectors play a crucial role in balancing supply and demand across borders. During peak demand periods in the UK, energy can be imported from countries with surplus capacity, such as France or Norway. France, with its extensive nuclear power fleet, often has excess electricity, making it a reliable source. Similarly, Norway’s abundant hydroelectric power offers a stable and renewable energy supply. This cross-border energy exchange helps mitigate the risks associated with sudden spikes in electricity demand or unexpected drops in renewable energy generation.
Renewable energy sources like wind and solar offer significant variability in power generation due to their reliance on environmental factors. Interconnectors help manage this variability by allowing excess renewable energy generated in one country to be exported to another. For example, on particularly windy days, the UK can export surplus wind-generated electricity to neighbouring countries, ensuring that this renewable resource is utilised efficiently rather than wasted.
Addressing energy security concerns
While interconnectors enhance energy security by providing access to a broader energy market, they also introduce certain vulnerabilities. Dependence on external energy supplies can expose countries to geopolitical risks and market fluctuations. For example, disruptions in interconnector cables, whether due to technical failures or geopolitical tensions, can lead to significant supply shortfalls. The fire at the UK end of the main French interconnector in 2021, which caused a substantial reduction in available electricity, is a case in point. Such incidents underscore the importance of maintaining and protecting these critical infrastructures.
Despite their benefits, interconnectors are not a panacea. They complement but do not replace the need for robust domestic energy policies and infrastructure. The UK, for example, continues to invest in its renewable energy projects, battery storage systems, and alternative technologies like hydrogen to enhance energy self-sufficiency. Interconnectors, while vital, are part of a broader strategy to create a resilient, low-carbon energy system.
Developing a comprehensive energy strategy
As we address these multifaceted challenges, the development of a comprehensive and adaptable energy strategy becomes crucial. This strategy must expedite the deployment of renewable energy sources while also enhancing the grid’s flexibility and resilience to effectively manage fluctuating supply and demand. As mentioned, we know that BESS can only act as a short-term solution at best when our wind turbines are not producing enough energy and this then leaves us relying on our gas capacity or interconnectors with overseas energy providers. This will become increasingly important given the predicted rise in the UK’s population and gradual electrification of heat and mobility, and so energy demand will only increase over the next decade. The need for a pragmatic approach that balances the UK’s ambitious renewable targets with the realities of technological and infrastructural limitations is key. Through informed strategies and innovative solutions, we can navigate our way to a reliable and efficient energy system that works for all.
This article by Gavin Bollan, Head of Corporate, Industrial & Manufacturing Sector at ITPEnergised appeared in New Energy World on 3 July 2024. For more information, please contact Gavin at gavin.bollan@itpenergised.com.
